I have been missing my Whitts, Big Bob Gibson's, Dreamland and Jim 'N Nick's like crazy-- but, now Hill Country Barbecue Market in Penn Quarter has filled my BBQ void. (http://www.hillcountrywdc.com/)
The place has that "trying to be country" look, but I won't hold it against them. The concept is really unique. When you walk into the restaurant you are in the bar area. The actual dining room is roped off behind the bar area. When it's time for you to be seated at a table you are taken into the dining area and given a card with the entire menu on it. The tables are set up to where you can eat at a table with people you don't know-- sort of cafeteria style. Or, if you are a large enough group you can all sit at the same table.
The waiter takes your drink order, writes it on your card, and sends you on your way to the food area. In the food area there is a butcher section, a "sides" section and a desserts section. You get to pick out the meat, sides and desserts you want and they mark off what you got on your card. I've been where there is a huge line in the food area and I've been when it was just a couple of people.
The portions are MASSIVE, so sharing everything is a great way to try out all the different food. I've tried the ribs, pulled chicken, Kreuz sausage (jalapeƱo cheese and regular), and the moist and lean brisket. For the sides, I've tried the green bean casserole, mac & cheese, collard greens, corn pudding, sweet potato bourbon mash and the baked beans. For dessert I've tried the peanut butter and jelly cupcake, the banana pudding and the bread pudding. ---- I recommend everything!!
My favorites would have to be the sausage, green bean casserole, mac & cheese, corn pudding and the banana pudding. So, basically everything on the menu.
They also serve Blue Bell Ice Cream (vanilla, strawberry, chocolate.) This is apparently a huge deal to everyone here because they have never had it before. --I know, hilarious right? My friends are addicted to this ice cream now and almost died when I told them that there is a creamery in Alabama and that it is in every flavor in every grocery store in the entire state of Alabama. And that yes, there were more flavors than vanilla, strawberry and chocolate.
There is also live music downstairs in the basement bar. I had not heard bluegrass or live country music since I've been here and it was good to feel at home again. People don't usually dance to live bands in bars the way they do down South (my boyfriend had never really heard of fraternity "band parties," which are a staples on game weekends, in bars, and even at high school sorority parties. Oh how I miss you Alabama culture) and I got all nostalgic at the bar and started missing the bars back home. A few older couples (much older, like 60) started dancing and I was dying to get out there and start dancing. The only annoying part is that there isn't an actual dance floor-- you just have to dance to the sides of the stage and off to the side of the tables. Next time I'm either going to teach my guy friends how to dance to that kind of music, or I'm going to borrow one of those 60-year- old's husbands.
The drinks are also amazing. They had a bunch of bourbon specials, which the boys loved, and a bunch of mixed drinks to choose from. My favorite was their spin on a Firefly and Lemonade, which was delicious.